The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
2 FOLLOWERS
Find notes on Jewish theology and spirituality on The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog. I am Alan Brill, a professor at Seton Hall of Interfaith, Jewish Thought, Spirituality, Modern Orthodoxy, and Kabbalah. I create this blog page to share my views, and opinions and discuss ideas.
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
God in Search of Man —Avot 3:14). When Green writes of the personal God, we get no sense of that God’s immense, immeasurable love and compassion ( I am grateful to Art for mentioning my work on Heschel, and I am grateful to Alan Brill for giving me a chance to respond to Art’s ideas. May this and may it serve are a declaration of monotheism (or of something approaching it). If other passages focus on God being the only god Israel may worship, this verse seems to insist that God is the only god– period. God alone is God. Nothing but God is God. ). No biblical ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
13. We are heirs to one of the world’s great spiritual traditions. We recognize that Torah is our people’s unique language for expressing an ancient and universal truth. For many centuries, persecution and hatred made it the legacy of Jews alone. While its exclusively inward-looking focus gave it great depth, in our age it needs to breathe deeply the air of freedom, broadening its focus and addressing the great issues that confront all humanity. As we join with other seekers in the quest for that universal truth, we remain committed to preserving our ancient language an ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
Copyright- Alan Brill & Levi Morrow My Covenant of Peace: Right and Left, War and Peace . This is not to say that politics is not the will of God, or that politics should not be organized according to halakhah. It’s just that we cannot contain politics and war within the category of “ ” In my opinion, Rambam sensed that it was dangerous to include war in the category of “ is rigid, transcendent, eternal, supernatural, unchanging, and stands outside of ongoing history ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
That ideology was modulated by a greater tendency to moderation and compromise, which is generally, unfortunately, less common among religious Zionist leaders today. Nonetheless, I think that Herzog’s persistent belief that bringing secular law to Israel was like “divorcing the Torah” became imprinted on the character of the mainstream religious Zionist movement. With the rise of Gush Emunim – along with other political and social changes in Israeli society such as the decline of Labor Zionism – the theocratic urge, less tempered by the values of moderation and unity, became more pronounced. A ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
Although I have taught international law for more than 30 years, I do not have the disciplinary hubris to think that it will provide the real-world key to healing Israel’s fragmentation. The recent “Nation-State Law” clearly signals a move in the opposite direction. Nonetheless, there is growing international legal scrutiny of events in Israel and the Palestinian Territories, highlighted by the recent ICC decision. May international law yet play some role in providing a way out of fragmentation, as it did in Rabbi Herzog’s thinking – and as it did, however briefly, in relation to theocracy in ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
In Kellner’s next book (We are Not Alone: A Maimonidean Theology of the Other – Academic Studies Press, 2021) it is shown that Rambam’s messianism allows us to live in hope and therefore work for a better future: what is, is not what must be. What is Maimonides’ view of the Messiah? ] of their Creator to the utmost capacity of the human mind?” Printed editions have for generations written that it will be “Israel.” However, that word is not found in the best manuscripts. Is it Israel, as the printed editions have it, or all human beings as the best manuscripts seem to teach? In our book, we pro ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
This was one of the reasons evoked by Jewish thinkers to make the point that Heidegger’s philosophy was ill-suited for Jewish thought. Insofar as his understanding of human existence bore an inherent Christian charge, it could not be applied to the specific case of Jewish existence. he sought to develop a philosophical scheme that was not beholden to metaphysical and Christian assumptions about what it means to be human. In this sense, his philosophy is decidedly non-Christian, and at times even anti-Christian. (1965), where he speaks of two kinds of communities, the natural community and the ..read more
The Book of Doctrines and Opinions Blog
1y ago
(1969) he developed a dialogical understanding of space. A place in which dialogical moments of time are not alien. The place in which our parents fell in love is deeply meaningful for us. If one comes to such a place with open heart, the place becomes a dwelling place for time (the love of our parents inspires us there). Then, instead of objectification of this place, one will hope to make it a place of love, of equality and peace. Heschel called Israel to remember that the Holy Land is not a place to be objectified. Open your hearts to the moments between God and Isaiah or Jeremiah, and to t ..read more