Bava Metzia 50: Fraud at a Sixth
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
19h ago
Establishing ona'ah at pricing that is a sixth over the value - with that time frame to consult and complain as temporary recourse. When is the sale considered final? Is that time limit really necessary? Also, once there's fraud, does it matter how extreme the fraud is? (Yes) Or how long the deadline really is? A close reading of the mishnah helps explain the overcharge ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 49: A Halakhic Better Business Bureau
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
2d ago
Reneging on a verbal commitment toward a sale - illustrative stories. Also, a new mishnah! On "ona'ah" - cases of taking advantage of another in a measurable way that is already determined to be problematic. Plus, terms whereby a customer can walk back terms that smack of ona'ah ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 48: Divine Retribution
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
3d ago
The daf explores the idea of Mi Sh’Para and what happens of someone reneges on a sale and the beit din cannot enforce the sale ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 47: The Significance of a Handkerchief
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
4d ago
Defining "kinyan sudar" - a handkerchief version of halipin. Plus, "kinyan agav," where the act of acquisition is secondary and along the way of the acquisition of something else, usually movable items along with a purchase of land. Also, using exchange when you have no money or anything else of value to use for purchase ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 46: The Exchange Without the Stock
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
4d ago
More on exchange - including the question of using a coin as an indication of a formal act of acquisition. For it to work, he has to already have the coins in hand. Otherwise, it's too close to a sale. Also, Rav Nachman's opinion, the idea that money does effect the purchase by Torah law, and the exchange of money bags ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 45: The Power of Exchange
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
5d ago
One who redeems ma'aser sheni on coins, and the desacralizes the coins to use them to buy the food in Jerusalem - how those coins can be exchanged, a dispute between Beit Shammai vs. Beit Hillel. Plus, the sourcing of the word "money" twice in the biblical verse. Also, when money is an exchange instead of a sale or a purchase payment ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 44: Commodity vs. Currency
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
1w ago
The third perek finished with a discussion about whether intent to misappropriate a deposit is misappropriation. The fourth perek begins with a mishnah discussing how objects are acquired ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 43: Drinking the Stash
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
1w ago
2 mishnayot! Additional cases of an object left with a guardian, and how various variables change the guardian's liability. Note the differences between a store keeper, a money changer, and a guardian. Plus, the complications of a change in value and the obligation to replace an unprotected item. Also, when one has to pay the increased value, for wine, for example. Plus, Rabbi Akiva's opinion upheld ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 42: To Be a Proper Guardian
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
1w ago
A new mishnah! When a guardian doesn't take good care to protect coins... when is he liable? With a focus on the verses that insist on proper supervision. Also, the blessing that only appears in that which is not obviously visible. Plus, storing money in a place that is protected from one potential threat, but subject to another one. Likewise, the question of whether negligence is relevant when a guardian puts the thing he's protecting under the protection of another. With a slew of cases to explore ..read more
Visit website
Bava Metzia 41: Moving the Barrel
Talking Talmud
by Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
1w ago
The daf discusses the last mishnah on 40 about whether a barrel being watched may be moved. A disagreement is presented between Rav and Levi if an act is considered misappropriation only if there is actual depletion of the object’s value ..read more
Visit website

Follow Talking Talmud on FeedSpot

Continue with Google
Continue with Apple
OR