Ohhhhh HELLO!!! As a surprise to ALL of us, here is the LONG awaited second half of Survivor Season 12. Although this episode was technically recorded all the way back in April, it is coming out hot and FRESH to you all today. Peter and Nell talk the chaos and mayhem that is Shane and annoying person extraordinaire Courtney; newsflash: if you’re annoying just OWN IT!! Cirie has to pull doctor duty as Shane full Winnie The Poohs it, Nell and Peter discuss how much of a flop Terry is, and Aras is identified as a cutie - how EMBARRASSING. All of that and plenty more in this HIGHLY anticipated epi ..read more

After a slightly longer than intended hiatus, the podcast is back and ready as ever to finish up their recap of Season 9: Vanuatu! Although it starts with some male flops, Nell and Peter sadly have to preside over the downfall of the at one point inspiring women’s alliance. They discuss gay rights icon and local wordsmith/zinger writer Ami, pray for Eliza even though she is an Icon for the history books, and bring up the important question of which Chris Daughtry came first? All of that and plenty more in this COVID brain filled episode. Be sure to check out idols.icons.eyerolls on instagram f ..read more

Welcome to the start of what the podcast would argue is hands down the best era of Survivor - Season 9 Vanuatu recap is HERE! Tune in this week to here some early stanship of WOMEN, the flopping of one castaway in particular, and some pretty stellar analysis of our favorite part of survivor: the numbers game. Getting ready for a short, but fun filled episode this week! You definitely won’t want to miss out. Be sure to check out idols.icons.eyerolls on instagram for more content! Full watching order from Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/comments/99b7yp/survivor_complete_watching_order_ ..read more

The mamas are back and oh baby were they chatty this week!! Welcome into a very special episode: the recap of the second half of Survivor: All-Stars. The star studded cast of the podcast expanded on this week's episode with the addition of very special guest host, Ellis Roesler, joining the crew all the way from what Peter claims is potato famine-era Dublin. She's studying to get her master's and after just two weeks of grad school she starts laying down some facts and hot takes for Peter and Nell. This episode includes scathing reviews of who got asked to compete as an "All-Star", the authent ..read more

The Unplanned Hiatus has ended? Yes - for now! The first season of returners? You betcha! One of the funniest episodes so far? Boy hopefully you think so too! WELCOME BACK ALL - STARS AND WELCOME BACK VIEWERS, READERS, AND LISTENERS! On this podcast episode, Nell and Peter finally get to dive into their first season of returning survivors and oh wow is it a GOOD one. There are some twists, turns, and even a blindside or two to recap so be sure to tune into this very fun, very chaotic, very stan culture episode. As you all know, this podcast loves a group of people who have energy so you better ..read more

Hulu rights are human rights - or so Peter claims in this week’s episode. The podcast is coming out swinging this week with some bold claims about one of America’s most talked about Survivor Seasons: Season 6 The Amazon. For inquiring minds, if you’re a fan of Joe Rogan and/or Banana Splits this is NOT the podcast for you. The boy girl narrative is heavily analyzed and some less than stellar reviews of certain castaways are fully unpacked on this week’s episode so you’ll definitely want to tune in! There is plenty more recapped in this episode, so you won’t want to miss! Be sure to check out i ..read more

The podcast is back and better than ever! After a brief hiatus, Nell and Peter come back in full swing to begin their recap of Survivor: The Amazon. Filled with gender wars and moments of pure flop behavior, this is a recap and a season you simply will not want to miss. We've got girl bosses, showmances, and raw chunks of meat hanging on hooks - what else could you ask for! If you really want to be in the know for this recap, be sure to catch up on every single episode of River Monsters, iykyk. Be sure to check out idols.icons.eyerolls on instagram for more content! Full watching order from Re ..read more

Boston Rob Stans - TURN BACK NOW!! Okay, but not like actually actually (okay maybe). This week's recap includes plenty of drags and critiques as always, but also some appreciate for the finer things in life - like early 2000s feminism in action on our TV screens. The longing for crowds and large parties continues to grow as Nell and Peter try to figure out a way onto a Survivor Reunion show. Plenty of callbacks and inside jokes on this week's episode so be sure to tune in NOW! Be sure to check out idols.icons.eyerolls on instagram for more content! We have an exciting announcement coming soon ..read more

Come one, come all and welcome to the only recap podcast that's willing to have discourse on proper sea urchin sting treatment! Nell and Peter do a deep dive into the fake narratives being spread regarding sea urchin and jellyfish stings as they recap Survivor: Marquesas. Cold and hot takes abound in this week's episode as the podcast discusses the flawed strategy of certain survivors, the decisions made my producers, and how people with Southern accents have a chokehold on Peter! There is plenty more recapped in this episode, so you won’t want to miss! Be sure to check out idols.icons.eyeroll ..read more

The podcast turns 18 (episodes old)!! Ring in adulthood with Nell, Peter, and the whole podcast crew on this special episode recapping the second half of Survivor: Africa. If anyone reading this is hoping for a job at National Geographic, you need to tune into this episode and also checkout nature being captured in its purest form by the Survivor production team. Valid critiques regarding strategy and more specifically, the lack of "talking a little strat", are made as well as picking apart the mechanics of sprinting over a cargo net (friends and fans are welcome to chime in on this one). Tear ..read more