I have said I wasn’t going to attempt to teach an entire graduate course on galaxy dynamics in this forum, and I’m not. But I can give some pointers for those who want to try it for themselves. It also provides some useful context for fans of Deur’s approach. The go-to textbook for this topic ..read more

Given recent developments in the long-running hunt for dark matter and the difficulty interpreting what this means, it seems like a good juncture to re-up* this: The history of science is a decision tree. Vertices appear where we must take one or another branching. Sometimes, we take the wrong road for the right reasons. A ..read more

I want to take another step back in perspective from the last post to say a few words about what the radial acceleration relation (RAR) means and what it doesn’t mean. Here it is again: This information was not available when the dark matter paradigm was developed. We observed excess motion, like flat rotation curves ..read more

In the previous post, we discussed how lensing data extend the Radial Acceleration Relation (RAR) seen in galaxy kinematics to very low accelerations. Let’s zoom out now, and look at things at higher accelerations and from a historical perspective. This all started with Kepler’s Laws of Planetary Motion, which are explained by Newton’s Universal Gravitation ..read more

Flat rotation curves and the Baryonic Tully-Fisher relation (BTFR) both follow from the Radial Acceleration Relation (RAR). In Mistele et al. (2024b) we emphasize the exciting aspects of the former; these follow from the RAR in the Mistele et al. (2024a). It is worth understanding the connection. First, the basic result: Figure 2 from Mistele et al. (2024a). The RAR from weak lensing data (yellow diamonds) is shown together with the binned kinematic RAR from Lelli et al. (2017, gray circles). The solid line is Newtonian gravity without dark matter (gobs = gbar). The shaded region at gbar < ..read more

That rotation curves become flat at large radii is one of the most famous results in extragalactic astronomy. This had been established by Vera Rubin and her collaborators by the late 1970s. There were a few earlier anecdotal cases to this effect, but these seemed like mild curiosities until Rubin showed that the same thing was true over and over again for a hundred spiral galaxies. Flat rotation curves took on the air of a de facto natural law and precipitated the modern dark matter paradigm. Optical and radio data Rotation curves shouldn’t be flat. If what we saw was what we got, the rotatio ..read more

This is an update to a post from a few years ago, which itself was an update to a webpage I wrote in 2008, with many updates in between. At that time, the goalposts for detecting WIMPs had already moved repeatedly. I felt some need then to write down a brief synopsis of the history of a beloved hypothesis (including by myself) that had obviously failed as the goalposts were in motion again. That was sixteen years ago. It is important to remember where we started from, which is now ancient history lost in the myths of time to most who are now working in the field. Indeed, when I search for men ..read more

I have been spending a lot of time lately writing up a formal paper on high redshift galaxies, so haven’t had much time to write here. The paper is a lot more involved than I told you so, but yeah, I did. Repeatedly. I do have a start on a post on self-interacting dark matter that I hope eventually to get back to. Today, I want to give a quick note about the MHONGOOSE survey. But first, a non-commercial interruption. Triton Station joins Rogue Scholar In internet news, Triton Station has joined Rogue Scholar. The blog itself hasn’t moved; Rogue Scholar is a community of science blogs. It provi ..read more

We will return to our usual programming shortly. But first, a few words on the eclipse experience last Monday. It. Was. Awesome. That’s a few words, so Mission Accomplished. That’s really all I had planned to say. However, I find I am still giddy from this momentous event, so will share my experience of the day, such as words can humbly convey. Prelude We had good weather here in Cleveland, with the temperature reaching the upper 60s Fahrenheit. It was cloudy in the morning and many people were concerned about the prospects to see the eclipse. I was not. Having spent a lifetime as an observer ..read more

The day of doom approaches, and the moon is cleft in half! Ayah al-Qamar 54:1 Perhaps the most compelling astronomical phenomenon accessible to a naked-eye observer is a total eclipse of the sun. These rare events have always fascinated us, and often terrified us. It is abnormal and disturbing for the sun to be blotted from the sky! A solar eclipse will occur on Monday, 8 April 2024. A partial eclipse will be visible from nearly every part of North America. The path of totality will sweep from Mexico through Texas, the Midwest, New England, and across the maritime provinces of Canada. If you ..read more